Thursday, December 22, 2011

Court Fees

Everyone has equal access to the courts, that is, IF you have money.  I have often been troubled by the fact that many hesitate to use the legal system because they can't afford all the fees and costs associated with it.

For example, imagine a mother who has some concerns about the safety of her children while they have placement with their father.  Maybe the children are returning with bruises.  Maybe the children return starving and dirty.  Maybe the mother has recently learned that the father has been seen doing drugs while his children are there.  The mother may report these things to the police and/or child protective services.  But what if this isn't quite enough for child protective services to step in and do something?

In Washington County, before even being allowed to file a motion to modify placement, the mother would have to request mediation (which has a fee).  After mediation fails, she would be able to file a motion (which has fees) and before even having a hearing the court almost always appoints a guardian ad litem (which requires a $1000 deposit which the party initiating the action pays).  And depending on the case and the guardian ad litem, the parties would likely be ordered to pay additional money for the guardian ad litem.  Then often a home custody study is ordered (which has a substantial fee).

If a fee waiver is approved, the filing fee and part of the mediation fee can be waived.  Even the guardian ad litem deposit can be waived.  But regardless of ability to pay at the end of the case, the parties are typically ordered to pay back guardian ad litem fees and home custody study fees.

Now, imagine that the mother recently separated from an abusive partner who is also the father of her children. Her abusive partner likely did not allow her to work and did not give her access to the money.  She is likely struggling to keep a roof over her and her children's heads.  How would she pay back the court for these fees?